Can Stuttering Therapies Work Effectively?
Some people feel that stuttering therapies cannot possibly be 100% effective, since there are such wide-ranging degrees of success given to any stuttering treatment. Perhaps the best they can hope for is some degree of satisfaction from the stutterer, which can be achieved by at least reducing the stuttering. Many say that the best treatment remedies improve self-confidence and language skills. Most doctors say treating stuttering in adults takes a combination approach that treats emotional effects and disfluency.
With regard to children, it was discovered that a computer-based anti-stuttering program with minimal interaction from speech-language pathologists held the most promise for keeping disfluency rates below 2%. In the 1996 “Controlled Clinical Trial for Stuttering in Persons Aged 9 to 14 Years,” researchers found that 71% of the children treated with computer programs and minimal speech pathologist interaction became fluent, compared to 63% of the children whose parents were trained by a speech pathologist to complete therapy at home, and 48% of children treated by the actual pathologist him/herself. These findings shed light on the important role of family when it comes to language skills.
Stuttering modification therapy is one of the more traditional stuttering therapies used today. Developed by Charles Van Riper between 1936 and 1958, this approach focuses on changing the portions of speech affected by stuttering. The idea is that patients can work through the underlying avoidance, anxiety and nervousness they feel through motivation, identification, desensitization, variation, approximation and stabilization. Tactics might include stuttering on purpose to reduce anxiety associated with the errors and seeking out social situations that may have been previously avoided. A person who stutters will also learn techniques to minimize or recoup from the disorder.
Experts say self-therapy is important for any of the stuttering therapies. In his book “Self-Therapy for the Stutterer,” Stuttering Foundation of America originator Malcolm Fraser said that those who stutter should make a habit of talking slow and deliberately; speaking easily, gently and without force; and taking advantage of block correction procedures. A stutterer should approach the issue directly, rather than try to hide the truth, and should focus on eliminating facial contortions, jaw tensing, rapid blinking and other reactions. The best approach is to practice speaking with varying inflections and melody and to continue moving forward with speech, rather than back-tracking or repeating.
As a leading expert in the field of anxiety disorders and panic attacks, Beth Kaminski is always on the lookout for how to treatment for anxiety attacks. Visit her site for more information on her treating panic disorder and much more.
